DE | EN
DE | EN

Seven Implications

Public Value Bericht 2015/16: Univ.Prof. Dr. Gregory F. Lowe – University of Tampere



There are seven implications that should be especially noted by those who will be involved in creating social impact assessment criteria and procedures for PSM organizations:

1. Embrace PSM's intrinsic values

An organization must be distinctive to compete effectively, but it can't be that if it fails to embrace intrinsic values that are endemic to it. It is worrisome to hear PSM managers devalue citizenship and prioritize customers. This notion can be useful in efforts to change internal culture to become more mindful of the competitive situation, but a public institution is not a private company. It is worrisome, as well, to find young employees with little understanding of what public service means in media, or how PSM is different from for-profit media. Intrinsic values matter today as much as ever.

2. From intrinsic to use value

The worth of intrinsic values must be operationalized as use value. Impact is determined by actual use. If people don't access and use PSM services then, de facto, they aren't services and the institution does not matter except in principle. Achieving improvement in use value demands a lot of the enterprise. PSM must be far less paternalistic, self-protective, self-sufficient, and self-satisfied and much more facilitative, inclusionary and knowledgeable about what people want and need, and how they live.

3. Exchange value must be sustainable

This requires tough decisions about what to do, what to stop doing, how to organize and practice with increasing efficiency, and how much to pay for what in order to achieve which ends. Competition is not all that matters and being obviously distinctive is crucial for PSM's sustainability. No PSM firm can have unique social impact if it is no different from its for-profit competitors.

4. A long-term strategic focus

The managers of PSM organizations should resist the strong pressures to focus on short-term needs and discipline their thinking to always take a long-term strategic view of the enterprise. They are not owners of these firms - they are stewards of a public trust.

5. Value varies

PSM does not have the same value for all people; it does not have the same value for anyone all the time; and it will be valued differently in varied contexts. Far more effort and investment is needed to develop nuanced understandings of PSM's value among different people in different situations with different needs and at different times. PSM must always be a developmental enterprise. Managers and makers need to be competent in critical thinking and focused on continual improvement.

6. Empirical evidence is needed

Today, exchange value is as important as intrinsic value. PSM organizations need indicators to empirically demonstrate improvements in both productivity and efficiency. It's crucial to provide evidence of how good a value the organization is providing for the money it receives. I suspect such measures will show the public gets better value for what it spends on PSM than what it spends for commercial services as a whole. There is little doubt that PSM organizations in Europe are doing far more with far less, and most of it much better. But where is the empirical evidence? There is not nearly enough of that for both separate companies or the sector as a whole.

7. The public determines value

The individuals using PSM products and services determine its practical value. Managers and makers have key roles in establishing the parameters, but they cannot determine the results. As Peter Drucker wisely observed, the only thing a company creates internally is cost. The value it creates is always and only external. Any company that puts its institutional self-interests above the needs, wants and preferences of an evolving public practice in media use is not sustainable.

Der Autor
Gregory F. Lowe ist Universitätsprofessor an der »School of Communication, Media and Theatre« der Universität von Tampere.

[Download Studie "Public Social Value"]
[Download Public-Value-Bericht]



#Keep Media Good, A unique pan-European recording of Charpentier’s Te Deum abspielen
© RTE
#Keep Media Good
A unique pan-European recording of Charpentier’s Te Deum
STUDIE - Allianzen, Kooperationen, Plattformen, Gemeinwohlorientierte Medienqualität in der Netzwerkgesellschaft abspielen
© ORF
STUDIE - Allianzen, Kooperationen, Plattformen
Gemeinwohlorientierte Medienqualität in der Netzwerkgesellschaft
Contribution to Society - Mehrwert für die Gesellschaft, Tanja Meyerhofer, EBU abspielen
Contribution to Society - Mehrwert für die Gesellschaft
Tanja Meyerhofer, EBU
Der Vorteil des Dreiländerecks, Iris Hofmeister, ORF Kärnten abspielen
© ORF
Der Vorteil des Dreiländerecks
Iris Hofmeister, ORF Kärnten
Es brennt ein Feuer in Europa, Margit Desch, Radiodirektion abspielen
© ORF/Ramstorfer
Es brennt ein Feuer in Europa
Margit Desch, Radiodirektion
Innovation, »The courage to change« abspielen
Innovation
»The courage to change«
Hate Speech, »A tremendous challange for PSM« abspielen
Hate Speech
»A tremendous challange for PSM«
Universality and Diversity, »Backbone of quality journalism« abspielen
Universality and Diversity
»Backbone of quality journalism«
Civil Society, »Public service broadcasting has to serve the public« abspielen
© ORF/EBU
Civil Society
»Public service broadcasting has to serve the public«
Independence and Media Accountability, EBU: »Quality programming needs proper funding« abspielen
© ORF\EBU
Independence and Media Accountability
EBU: »Quality programming needs proper funding«
Seven Implications, Public Value Bericht 2015/16: Univ.Prof. Dr. Gregory F. Lowe – University of Tampere abspielen
Seven Implications
Public Value Bericht 2015/16: Univ.Prof. Dr. Gregory F. Lowe – University of Tampere
Vision 2020, Public Value Bericht 2015/16: Ruurd Bierman – EBU abspielen
© ORF
Vision 2020
Public Value Bericht 2015/16: Ruurd Bierman – EBU
Texte 14: ESC - More than music?, By Karen Fricker, Harald Huber und Irving Wolther et al. abspielen
Texte 14: ESC - More than music?
By Karen Fricker, Harald Huber und Irving Wolther et al.
Texte 13 - Sonderheft zum Public Value Bericht 13/14, Contributions of all 27 EU member states abspielen
Texte 13 - Sonderheft zum Public Value Bericht 13/14
Contributions of all 27 EU member states
Universalität der Inhalte und Dienste, Nicola Frank, EBU abspielen
Universalität der Inhalte und Dienste
Nicola Frank, EBU
Why Greece matters: Values debate in sharp focus, Ingrid Deltenre, Director General of EBU abspielen
Why Greece matters: Values debate in sharp focus
Ingrid Deltenre, Director General of EBU
EBU Core Values, Empowering Society abspielen
EBU Core Values
Empowering Society
Der gesellschaftliche Wert öffentlich-rechtlicher Medien, Ingrid Deltenre, EBU Generaldirektorin abspielen
Der gesellschaftliche Wert öffentlich-rechtlicher Medien
Ingrid Deltenre, EBU Generaldirektorin
Europa und die Welt. Beispiele der EBU-Zusammenarbeit, Nicola Frank, EBU Brüssel abspielen
Europa und die Welt. Beispiele der EBU-Zusammenarbeit
Nicola Frank, EBU Brüssel
Die Berichterstattung verbessern, Gudrun Gutt, Newsdesk abspielen
Die Berichterstattung verbessern
Gudrun Gutt, Newsdesk